May 22nd, 2008


history is dead.

From a review of the new Indy movie, Annalee Newitz of has the following observation:

The only edge to the film is a clumsy, knee-jerk liberal subplot about how the evil U.S. government suspects everyone of being part of the Red Menace — even Indy! Sounds just like the evil, suspicious U.S. government today! Wow, thanks for the commentary, but honestly if there had just been cooler aliens or a weirder plot I would have been a lot happier.

The movie is set in the 1950s. Now you can see why I just sighed to myself and muttered, “History is dead…”

Look, McCarthyism and the whole paranoia over the Red Menace was real, and it destroyed lives. If you’re seeing parallels to today’s US government in it, then maybe y’ought to be more scared, y’know?

Originally published at You can comment here or there.